2023: 19-3-1, 11-0 Heart (Heart Regular Season Champions, NAIA National Tournament Quarterfinals)
2022: 19-3-1, 11-0-1 Heart (Regular Season and Tournament Champions, NAIA National Tournament Opening Round)
2021: 22-2, 12-0 Heart (Regular Season and Tournament Champions, NAIA National Tournament Semifinals)
2020-21: 20-4-1, 10-2 Heart (Regular Season and Tournament Champions, NAIA National Tournament Quarterfinals)
2019: 22-0-1, 11-0 Heart (Regular Season and Tournament Champions, NAIA National Tournament Round of 16)
2018: 16-6, 9-2 Heart (NAIA National Tournament Opening Round)
2017: 16-3-2, 10-1-1 Heart (Regular Season Champion, NAIA National Tournament Opening Round)
2016: 13-4-2, 7-3-2 Heart
2015: 11-6-3, 6-2-2 Heart
2014: 9-4-5, 1-4-2 Heart
2013: 9-7-2, 1-4-2 Heart
2012: 11-7, 2-5 Heart
2011: 14-3-2, 4-2-1 Heart
2010: 3-12-3, 0-8-1 Heart
2009: 10-7-1, 3-6 Heart
2008: 6-12, 1-8 Heart
2007: 7-9-1, 1-6-1 Heart