2023-24: 19-10, 15-9 Heart
2022-23: 17-12, 14-8 Heart
2021-22: 22-11, 12-7 Heart (NAIA Opening Round)
2020-21: 11-13, 8-11 Heart
2019-20: 12-18, 11-13 Heart
2018-19: 17-14, 12-12 Heart
2017-18: 27-6, 15-4 Heart (Heart South Division Champion, NAIA National Tournament)
2016-17: 17-14, 14-12 Heart
2015-16: 15-16, 9-13 Heart
2014-15: 20-12, 9-9 Heart
2013-14: 18-13, 11-7 Heart
2012-13: 19-13, 11-7 Heart
2011-12: 14-15, 8-10 Heart
2010-11: 11-19, 6-14 Heart
2009-10: 24-9, 17-3 Heart (Regular Season Champion, NAIA National Tournament)
2008-09: 28-7, 16-4 Heart (NAIA National Tournament Second Round)
2007-08: 20-12, 14-6 Heart
2006-07: 17-14, 10-10 Heart
2005-06: 10-19, 7-13 Heart
2004-05: 14-17, 8-12 Heart
2003-04: 14-19, 8-12 Heart
