2023: 36-19, 23-7 Heart (Regular Season Champions & NAIA Opening Round)
2022: 42-15, 23-9 Heart (Tournament Champions & NAIA Opening Round)
2021: 49-8, 26-3 Heart (Conference Regular Season & Tournament Champions, NAIA Opening Round Champions, NAIA World Series Runner-Up)
2020: 16-5, 5-1 Heart (Shortened season due to COVID-19)
2019: 35-16, 19-8 Heart (NAIA Opening Round)
2018: 41-16, 23-8 Heart (Conference Regular Season Champions, NAIA Opening Round)
2017: 42-17, 23-9 Heart (Heart South Champions, NAIA Opening Round)
2016: 44-17, 23-9 Heart (Conference Tournament Champions, NAIA Opening Round)
2015: 26-28, 10-16 Heart
2014: 21-26, 12-14 Heart
2013: 25-13, 19-7 Heart (Conference Regular Season and Tournament Champions, NAIA Opening Round)
2012: 25-22, 14-11 Heart
2011: 22-24, 16-12 Heart
2010: 13-26, 10-18 Heart
2009: 15-29, 12-28 Heart
2008: 12-31, 5-16 Heart
2007: 8-39, 4-22 Heart
2006: 15-30, 9-15 Heart